Located at the end of Central Avenue on the West side of Hicksville Road. It is historically significant as an early Long Island religious site. It began in 1836. The church was built that year by its first pastor, Joshua Powell. Then in 1920 the church building was moved to its present location on Broadway, Bethpage, south of Central Avenue, and later expanded. The history of Bethpage, Plainedge and surrounding areas is preserved here. There are graves of Veterans from the Civil War, WWI, and WWII. Numerous interesting inscriptions and familiar family names are represented. A committee was organized in 2004, "Friends of Bethpage Methodist Cemetery Committee" to clean up the grounds of this ecumenical and historic holy burial ground.